Elsevier

Australian Critical Care

Volume 18, Issue 4, November 2005, Pages 158-165
Australian Critical Care

Best practice in stabilisation of oral endotracheal tubes: A systematic review

https://doi.org/10.1016/S1036-7314(05)80029-3Get rights and content

Abstract

Mechanical ventilation of patients in intensive care units is common practice. Artificial airways are utilised to facilitate ventilation and the endotracheal tube (ETT) is most commonly used for this purpose. The ETT must be stabilised to optimise ventilation and avoid displacement or unplanned extubation. Tube movement is a major factor in causing airway trauma. A destabilised tube can cause fatal complications. A systematic review was conducted to identify and analyse the best available evidence on ETT stabilisation to determine which stabilisation method resulted in reduced tube displacement and the least amount of unplanned or accidental extubations. The types of stabilisations included one or a combination of the following methods: twill or cotton tape, adhesive tape, gauze, or a manufactured device. All relevant randomised controlled and quasi-experimental studies of ETT stabilisation practices, identified through electronic and hand searching, were assessed for inclusion in the study. One published randomised controlled trial and six published quasi-experimental studies met the inclusion and exclusion criteria and were retrieved. Data were extracted independently by two reviewers. Results of the systematic review showed that no single method of ETT stabilisation could be identified as superior for minimising tube displacement and unplanned or accidental extubations. Rigorous randomised controlled trials with clearly identified and described ETT stabilisation methods are required to establish best practice. In addition, comparative research to evaluate cost effectiveness and nursing time requirements would also be of significant benefit to critical care nursing practice.

References (11)

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (35)

  • Effectiveness of nonpharmacological interventions to prevent adverse events in the intensive care unit: A review of systematic reviews

    2023, Australian Critical Care
    Citation Excerpt :

    The number of patients in the eligible studies ranged from 45432 to 336933 and was not reported or unknown in nine (24.3%) reviews. The included reviews covered 11 different AEs: ventilator-associated pneumonia (VAP) (11 SRs),33–43 delirium (six SRs),29,44–48 physical function deterioration (five SRs),32,49–52 reintubation (four SRs),53–56 medication error (three SRs),31,57,58 artificial airway occlusion or hospital-acquired pneumonia (two SRs),59,60 healthcare-associated infections (HAIs; two SRs),61,62 pressure injury (two SRs),30,63 and tube displacement or tube occlusion (two SRs).27,28,54 The total number of interventions evaluated was 27, and VAP was the most frequent AE studied with seven NPIs.

  • Tracheal Tube Position Shift during Infant Resuscitation by Chest Compression: A Simulation Comparison by Fixation Method and with or Without Cuff

    2016, Journal of Emergency Medicine
    Citation Excerpt :

    After confirmation of infant tracheal tube placement, tracheal tube fixation is highly critical because even a small tracheal tube shift can result in accidental extubation or one-lung ventilation. In adult studies, securing the tracheal tube during the use of a tube holder, or wire anchoring the tube to the oral cavity, can reduce the incidence of unplanned extubation (11,12). However, there are few studies regarding the best tube fixation method for infant resuscitation.

  • Novel device (AirWave) to assess endotracheal tube migration: A pilot study

    2013, Journal of Critical Care
    Citation Excerpt :

    It is not possible to determine from the data gathered in the present study whether the variations are due to imprecise determinations of the AirWave system or inaccuracies of the comparator, ie, CXR. Endotracheal tube lumen obstruction or narrowing secondary to endoluminal secretions, tube kinking, or extrinsic compression (eg, patient biting) may go undetected for extended periods and/or result in adverse patient outcomes [10,23-25]. A promising feature of the AirWave system relies on real-time monitoring of ETT lumen patency.

  • Self/Unplanned Extubation. Safety, Surveillance, and Monitoring of the Mechanically Ventilated Patient

    2012, Critical Care Nursing Clinics of North America
    Citation Excerpt :

    With any ETT fixation method, health care providers must remain vigilant in maintaining the integrity of the oral mucosa and facial skin in order to prevent injury from excess/prolonged pressure on any given area. Commonly used methods for ETT fixation include commercial tube holder devices, various types of tape (cloth, plastic, paper, and so forth), circumferential versus face-only taping, and suturing or wiring the ETT to teeth/surrounding tissues; however, no single method has been demonstrated as superior.44 It has been shown that ensuring proper attention and consistency in the method of securing the ETT decreases UE.45

View all citing articles on Scopus
View full text