A male patient in his 40s was transferred to our hospital for rehabilitation of ataxia after right cerebellar and brainstem infarction. After 3 weeks of conventional physical therapy, his activities of daily life successfully improved with an increase in the functional impedance measure from 101 to 124. However, he still fell short of gaining a higher level of balance function, which was necessary for his job as a standup forklift driver. We introduced virtual reality-guided balance training. The training was performed for approximately 40 min on weekdays for 2 weeks. As a result, the Scale for the Assessment and Rating of Ataxia score decreased from 5 to 1, Functional Balance Scale score improved from 48 to 56, and Mini-Balance Evaluation Systems Test score increased from 20 to 28. The trunk sway disappeared clinically. He regained confidence and returned to work after an additional 2 weeks of physical therapy.
- rehabilitation medicine
- physiotherapy (rehabilitation)
- virtual rehabilitation
- brain stem / cerebellum
This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/.
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Ataxia is defined as impaired coordination in the absence of motor paralysis or reduced consciousness, which impedes an individual’s ability to perform voluntary movements, making them unable to control their direction, force and speed.1–3 Cerebellar ataxia develops in a majority of patients with cerebellar stroke, with an estimated prevalence ranging from 51.3% to 67.5%.4 5 The loss of balance is one of the critical symptoms of cerebellar ataxia that should be addressed by active intervention since it not only causes clumsiness and sluggishness in limb movements but also symptoms like gait abnormalities can interfere in all aspects of life, including activities of daily living (ADLs) and social activities.6 7 Numerous training exercises to improve balance are available, including stepping, one-leg standing and ball-related and disc-related exercises; however, they have drawbacks such as monotony and challenges adjusting difficulty level. For resolving these issues, researchers overseas have begun to apply virtual reality (VR) technology in rehabilitation programmes targeting balance impairments; systematic reviews on VR-guided training’s effectiveness in improving balance have already been published after stroke or in elderly.8 9 However, there is insufficient evidence for the treatment of high-level balancing ability in the working generation. In Japan, mediVR KAGURA, a medical device designed for VR rehabilitation, was approved for clinical use in March 2019.10 11 In this report, we share our experience of a patient who developed cerebellar ataxia following a cerebellar/brainstem infarction, whose ataxia and balance were successfully improved by VR-guided rehabilitation using this device.
A middle-aged man in his 40s was affected by a right cerebellar/brainstem infarction. Before the stroke, he had been employed in the warehouse logistics, an environment requiring high levels of standing balance for operating forklifts. One day, he suddenly fell at his residence and was then rushed to the hospital. On arrival, consciousness disturbance, persistent gaze deviation, left haemiplegia and right cerebellar ataxia were noted. Diffusion-weighted cranial MRI performed the same day revealed an infarct in the right cerebellum and brainstem (figure 1). Following acute treatment and care, the patient was transferred to our hospital on the 37th day after onset for recovery-phase rehabilitation.
No obvious motor paralysis was noted at the time of transfer, and he was able to walk unassisted. However, cerebellar ataxia presenting as a rigid gait pattern was noted, with the patient locking his (left) knee during the left stance phase and shuffling the front of his (left) foot during the left swing phase. Additionally, during quick stepups, he required assistance owing to wobbling outside his control. His ADL performance was rated as ‘independent’ for all activities except for transferring and moving, where he was rated as ‘requiring supervision’ for safety concerns. Early return to work was the rehabilitation need of highest priority, as the patient was the main provider of his household.
For the first 3 weeks after admission to our hospital, the patient underwent a standard physical therapy (PT) programme focusing on balance training (unassisted step ups) and functional gait training (changing direction), with the goal of independent locomotion without assistance within the facility. This programme resulted in improved ADL functioning, including an increase in Functional Independence Measure total score from 101 to 124 pts; however, it did little to improve his coordination and balance-related issues (table 1).
Standard PT was supplemented with a voluntary rehabilitation exercise, which employed a VR medical device (‘VR rehabilitation’ below) initiating on the 23rd day of inpatient care at our hospital as a voluntary exercise for this purpose. The VR rehabilitation device (mediVR KAGURA: mediVR, Toyonaka, Japan) is capable of presenting an upper limb reaching task to a user seated in three-dimensional virtual space for the purpose of body balance training; the specific task was a kind of game in which the user reaches to make contact with a series of falling objects (figure 2). VR rehabilitation was introduced to help the patient regain the level of functional balance needed to return to his job: namely, the speed, location and the number of falling objects that were customised to train him how to smoothly shift his body weight when reaching. The patient underwent this VR-guided body balance training for 2 weeks, performing two 20 min sets per day, 5 days a week. Exercise intensity was calibrated by adjusting the speeds, locations and numbers of falling objects. Treatment efficacy was assessed by comparing the patient’s performance on several measures at baseline (admission to our hospital) with those recorded at the initial start of VR rehabilitation and after the final session. Ataxia was evaluated using the Scale for the Assessment and Rating of Ataxia (SARA). The Functional Balance Scale (FBS) was adopted to assess general balance ability and the Mini-Balance Evaluation Systems Test (Mini-BESTest) to assess more sophisticated high-level balance skills.
Outcome and follow-up
We followed up with the patient on an outpatient basis and confirmed a successful return to work.
Ataxia can hinder movements in any number of settings, whether in daily life or social rehabilitation.1–3 Balancing skills are essential for performing job-related movements, making their recovery an inseparable part of occupational rehabilitation, in addition to motor palsy and muscle strength. However, it is difficult to state that an effective functional training methodology, along with supporting evidence, has truly been established to treat ataxia and improve balance skills, especially when it comes to high-level balancing ability in the working generation.12 This can present a problem in the rehabilitation of patients such as the present case, where working-age individuals require a highly effective yet short-term training programme to hasten their return to the workplace. For our case, a standard rehabilitation programme did not result in sufficient improvement in measures of ataxia and balance (table 1), despite its targeted content, an intensive functional training programme lasting 3 weeks following inpatient admission focused on balance training (unassisted step ups) and functional gait training (changing direction). We believe that this failure was owing to challenges adjusting the existing training methods for ataxia and balance skills to levels matching our patient’s abilities.13 14 This concern led us to pursue the novel approach of VR-guided rehabilitation using a medical device, which has recently been reported effective in helping patients to recover balance-related skills after stroke or in elderly.8 9 We believe that some of our patient’s treatment success was attributed to the effectiveness of VR-guided rehabilitation using such a device, as indicated by the record improvements in all assessment scores after VR rehabilitation (SARA, FBS, Mini-BESTest) and the patient’s remarks about his recovery. We also speculate that the software options available to precisely and quantitatively configure the virtual objects’ attributes—including falling speed, location and count (figure 3) allowed us to resolve the usual challenges of adjusting task difficulty level encountered in traditional training exercises, leading to the patient’s functional recovery. Although this report is only described a single case and distinguishing it from a natural course is challenging, sufficient improvements in SARA, FBS, Mini-BESTest after introduction of VR-guided rehabilitation implies the utility of it.
Moreover, we believe that the patient’s recovery was assisted by the mediVR KAGURA’s provision of accurate feedback separately for each movement on every task/trial. Specifically, this device provides the user with visual, auditory and haptic feedback when they accurately make contact with a falling object in the form of text displayed on the screen, sounds and controller vibrations, respectively. Feedforward control concerning an ‘internal model’ has been proposed as a powerful hypothesis for motor control by the cerebellum.15 16 ‘Feedforward learning’, a motor learning process involving the repetition of movements at appropriate strengths, is considered necessary to the construction of this internal model.2 Patients with cerebellar ataxia are prone to reduced feedforward control, making accurate, external feedback necessary for correcting errors, thereby potentiating feedforward learning.2 17 However, some patients might not be able to gain sufficient feedback from the spoken remarks of therapists (as in standard rehabilitation programmes discussed above). Our patient’s functional recovery can be explained in the framework of the cerebellar internal model theory as follows. The patient’s immersion in the VR space permitted sensory feedback directly, in multiple forms, without any interference from the external environment. Therefore, this direct feedback fostered the feedforward learning for target movements better than conventional rehabilitation exercises. Additionally, several factors may underlie the mechanism by which seated balance training contributed to the recovery of standing balance performance: these include the fact that the upper body accounts for two-thirds of body mass,10 11 and that the patient’s lower extremities were naturally activated when he reached far beyond the base of support while seated in response to the resulting load placed on them in the direction of motion.11
VR-guided rehabilitation is highly reproducible since task speed and frequency can be precisely calibrated. It also offers objectivity and convenience, allowing practitioners to adjust the difficulty level according to an individual’s characteristics and easily develop and present highly sensitive, accurate and diverse feedback. The authors have described these benefits in detail above. Taking full advantage of such next-generation technologies should expand our range of treatments as therapists, helping more patients in recovery. Nonetheless, the evidence level for this VR-guided rehabilitation programme is a single case report, indicating that the therapeutic efficacy of such exercises must still be determined in interventional research such as randomised controlled trials. Readers should also keep in mind that the patient in our case presented with a relatively infrequent rigid gait pattern when interpreting the result. However, cerebellar lesions typically present with a broad-based gait.18 19 We anticipate that the promise of the VR-guided therapeutic intervention demonstrated in this case report serves to spark interventional research and foster medical progress in the field of high-level balance training of the working generation. Well-designed randomised controlled studies are needed to provide us with more accurate results in the near future.
Functional training for patients with cerebellar ataxia can be difficult in several cases, and the effective therapeutic strategies should be verified further.
Virtual reality (VR)-guided body balance training can be a therapeutic option for the treatment of cerebellar ataxia.
The effectiveness of VR-guided rehabilitation was indicated by the record improvements in Scale for the Assessment and Rating, Functional Balance Scale and Mini-Balance Evaluation Systems Test as well as by the patient’s remarks about his recovery.
Contributors KT，KO，YM，HI contributed to the conception and design of this case report, the acquisition and interpretation of data, and drafting or revising the manuscript critically for important intellectual content.
Funding The authors have not declared a specific grant for this research from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.
Disclaimer Case reports provide a valuable learning resource for the scientific community and can indicate areas of interest for future research. They should not be used in isolation to guide treatment choices or public health policy.
Competing interests YM is an employee of mediVR, a company that holds several patents on VR-guided rehabilitation. KT, KO and HI have no conflicts of interest to declare.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.