Summary

Parsonage-Turner syndrome (PTS) is a rare neuropathy that commonly presents as unexpected severe shoulder and arm pain that eventually subsides while weakness or paralysis ensues. During exceptions to this classic presentation, confirming PTS can be challenging. Alternative causes of upper extremity pain may confound the diagnostic algorithm. Moreover, objective findings from necessary diagnostic tests depend on when those tests are performed. We present an atypical onset of PTS, whereby the initial presentation of severe neuropathic pain was preceded by mild shoulder pain that should decrease one’s clinical suspicion for PTS. This milder pain coincided with the presence of a rotator cuff injury, whereby surgical intervention preceded impending paralysis and hindered postoperative rehabilitation. Physicians should be aware of the possibility of atypical presentations of PTS in hopes of avoiding either untimely surgery or delays in diagnosis.